When I read Louise Williams' A True Story of the Great Escape I did something I don't often do. I wrote two reviews. A short one which was published in Flightpath (and which appears on an early blog post) and longer review where I could explore more deeply some of the issues highlighted by Louise when she told her uncle's story. That review has now appeared on Aircrew Book Review, my favourite aviation book review site (and it is not my favourite just because Andy has invited me as a guest reviewer on a number of occasions, OR because Andy has reviewed four of my five books and I understand that in due course it become five out of five, but because Andy is such a thoughtful reviewer of good aviation books). Anyway, below is the long review as I wrote it. Follow the link for the final edited version!
A True Story of the Great Escape. A young Australian POW in the most Audacious Breakout of WWII by Louise Williams. Allen & Unwin, September 2015, 284 pages. ISBN: 9781743313893. $29.99
Published in Aircrew Book Review 24 March 2016. http://aircrewbookreview.blogspot.com.au/2016/03/a-true-story-of-great-escape-louise.html
The
author of A True
Story of the Great Escape is the niece of John
Williams, one of five Australians killed on Hitler’s order after the mass
breakout from Stalag Luft III. Little was known about John’s fate, other than
the fact of his death, and Louise Williams has devoted much of her life to discovering
exactly what happened.
John 'Willy' Williams http://www.smh.com.au/national/true-story-of-the-great-escape-20120316-1vac0.html
Despite
the author’s connection to John, this is not
just his story, nor is it simply a retelling of the Great Escape from an Australian
perspective. It follows the career of John’s friend and fellow escaper Reginald
‘Rusty’ Kierath. It encompasses those who were affected by John’s death,
particularly his mother, Mildred. It also chronicles a family’s unresolved
grief across half a century. Finally, it tells of Louise William’s journey to piece
together the jigsaw puzzle of John’s life and death and provide closure for herself
and her family.
Reg Kierath courtesy Peter Kierath
Williams
faced many challenges. Some of John’s letters were destroyed in storage, there are gaps in the
chronology where no records or witnesses exist, and other participants who
could have shed light are now dead. To overcome these obstacles, she had to
look sideways and around. Supplementing extracts from John’s extant letters,
family reminiscences, and official documents, Williams fleshes out the known with vivid genealogical surveys and explorations
of his school ethos, his home suburb, surf life-saving and surf sports. John is thus placed within a social and historical framework which illuminates
the scanty personal record.
Much of John’s Royal Air Force
service is known. He excelled as a trainee pilot and was granted a pre-war
short service commission. Instead of a posting to an operational squadron, he became
an instructor. After transferring to the Western Desert, he gained experience in
RAF squadrons before notching up a series of victories for 450 Squadron RAAF as
one of its new flight commanders. He gained a reputation as an aggressive pilot
and the culmination of his flying career came when he was promoted to commanding
officer. The 23-year-old’s promising leadership stint, however, was cut short
when he was shot down by one of his own men in October 1942 and taken prisoner.
What is not known is why
John embarked on the Great Escape and what happened in the moments before his
death. These essential mysteries are at the heart of A True Story of the Great
Escape. While
the author knows that these final secrets will probably never be uncovered, she
has provided some clues. Fellow escaper Bertram ‘Jimmy’ James, for example,
shares what went on his mind before and during the escape, thus giving some
hint to John’s thought processes. Perhaps the most telling clue, however, comes
from John’s close-knit family life which is lovingly described (with no sign of
rose-tinted glasses). Maintaining the familial link to her son, Mildred’s
weekly letters reinforced that John was a much-loved and much-missed son and
brother. John diligently wrote back, demonstrating that for him, too, the bonds
had not slackened during his long absence.
Captivity is not an easy
state but, for many, a continuing connection to home makes it bearable.
Paradoxically, that closeness also makes incarceration unbearable and some
yearn to go home. When that desire is enacted, the prisoner is willing to take
any risk, as John did. But when risk leads to death, grief is more intense than
if a beloved son had been lost in battle. There is honour in combat and solace
in knowing that he had done his duty in contributing to the undoubted victory
but, in breaching the Geneva Conventions which had provided surety of John’s safety,
there had been nothing honourable about his murder. Mildred’s grief was bitter
and intense. It was never assuaged, and percolated down to the next generation.
A True Story of the Great Escape is a saga of compelling sadness and keen tragedy.
Even so, we recognise the joy of a life lived well and full, despite its
brevity. Perhaps the central mysteries of John’s death can never be explained but
through Williams’ poignant account we gain a firm sense of the man and can
imagine why he participated in the Great Escape. Even if we don’t know exactly
what happened in his last moments, this moving and well-illustrated story of
discovery and the consequences of war leaves us in no doubt about its impact.
